Cards with Dredge MTG: When Can You Remove Them?

In Magic: The Gathering, cards with dredge abilities can be a game-changer in the right situations. However, when you're faced with a spell or ability that allows your opponent to choose between drawing a card and dredging, things can get confusing. In this article, we'll explore when you can remove these dredge cards and how priority works in Magic.

Take Brainstorm, for example, which has the following effect: 'Draw a card, then discard a card.' It's natural to think that you could remove one of your dredge cards before your opponent chooses to draw or dredge. Unfortunately, it doesn't work that way. According to the official Magic rules, when an ability allows a player to choose between drawing a card and dredging, they make that choice as soon as the ability is activated.

In other words, you can't wait to see what choice your opponent makes before removing the dredge card. This can be frustrating, especially if you're trying to stop them from getting ahead with their dredge strategy.

What about spells like Charms, which have multiple options? For instance, a Charm might allow the player to choose between drawing two cards and dredging three times or simply drawing one card. In this case, do you get a chance to remove any of your dredge cards at all?

The answer is no, you don't have the opportunity to remove any dredge cards once the ability has been activated. This can be especially challenging when facing opponents who use these types of spells to fuel their dredge strategy.

Now, what happens if you pass on your chance to respond to the spell or ability that allows a draw? Can you still remove the dredge card later in the turn?

The answer is yes, but only under certain circumstances. If an opponent uses a spell or ability that cycles, for example, priority can pass back to you during the resolution of that ability. This means that if you have Loam in your graveyard and your opponent cycles it, you might get a chance to remove it before they get the option to replace the draw with a dredge.

So, when do cards with dredge abilities use the stack? In general, any spell or ability that allows drawing a card uses the stack. This means that you can respond to these types of effects by removing your dredge cards, as long as you have priority and are able to respond before the effect resolves.

In conclusion, while it may seem like you're limited in your options when facing opponents who use cards with dredge abilities, there are still ways to disrupt their strategy. By understanding how priority works in Magic and being mindful of the timing of your opponent's spells and abilities, you can stay one step ahead and keep them from getting too far ahead.

So the next time you're facing an opponent who uses cards like Brainstorm or Charms to fuel their dredge strategy, remember that you do have options. With practice and patience, you'll be able to outmaneuver your opponents and come out on top.

Cards with dredge mtg